Select Page

The Digital Echoes of Discontent: Why Morocco’s Suppression of ‘GenZ 212’ Protests Carries Global Lessons

By [Your Professional Blog Name/Your Name], Analyzing Global Political Economy and Social Dynamics

The image is stark: a young man detained by police in Rabat, his attempt to protest for basic human rights—better healthcare and education—swiftly squashed. This snapshot, taken amidst a three-day crackdown in late September 2025, encapsulates a growing tension across North Africa: the collision between a digitally organized generation demanding social justice and a state prioritizing stability through suppression.

In Morocco, the demand for reform has coalesced around an anonymous, potent movement dubbed “GenZ 212.” What began as localized discontent over abysmal hospital conditions rapidly escalated into a multi-city call for systemic change, echoing sentiments that defined the region’s turning points over a decade ago. This deep dive analyzes the drivers of this youth-led crisis, the state’s severe response, and the crucial political lessons this scenario holds, even for distant models of governance like Singapore.

  1. The Algorithm of Activism: GenZ 212’s Digital Strategy

The “GenZ 212” movement is a textbook example of modern, decentralized activism. Untethered from traditional political parties or established civil society organizations, this protest wave was incubated and coordinated almost entirely on social media platforms—specifically TikTok, Instagram, and the encrypted chat application Discord.

The speed and reach of these platforms allowed the movement to jump from a local grievance in Agadir (sparked by frustrations over poor hospital conditions) to a national phenomenon demanding better public health and education in cities including Casablanca, Rabat, Tangier, and Oujda.

The demands are pointed and fundamental:

Systemic Healthcare Reform: Denouncing inadequate care, understaffed facilities, and critical lack of medical resources—issues the COVID-19 pandemic significantly magnified worldwide.
Quality Education: A demand for an education system that provides a real pathway to employment and future stability.
Social Justice Slogans: The adoption of phrases like “freedom, dignity, and social justice” is highly significant. These are the very slogans that fueled the 2011 Arab Spring demonstrations, which ultimately pressured Morocco’s monarchy into constitutional reforms. By invoking this language, GenZ 212 frames their struggle not just as a request for better services, but as a demand for a renewed social contract.

  1. The Weight of Unemployment: The Engine of Anger

To understand the ferocity of the protests, one must look beyond the immediate demands for hospital beds and textbooks and examine the staggering economic context. The frustration driving GenZ 212 is underpinned by a profound sense of generational blockage and economic despair.

Morocco’s official unemployment rate stands at 12.8%. However, the numbers hit youth disproportionately hard: youth unemployment is a staggering 35.8%. Crucially, the situation remains dire even for those who manage to graduate, with unemployment among graduates hovering around 19%.

This context provides the core analytical framework:

The Broken Promise: Young Moroccans are investing in education only to find themselves locked out of the formal economy.
The Vicious Cycle: Poor public healthcare limits mobility and quality of life, while substandard education fails to equip them for the job market.
A Failure of the Social Contract: When stability is enforced, but the state fails to deliver functioning public services or economic opportunities, the contract between the rulers and the ruled collapses, making protests inevitable.

  1. The State’s Immediate and Heavy-Handed Response

The Moroccan government’s reaction was immediate and uncompromising. Instead of opening a dialogue with the decentralized movement, the response focused on rapid containment and heavy suppression.

For three consecutive days, a robust security presence successfully prevented the planned protests from massing. The use of both uniformed and plainclothes officers ensured that any attempt to organize, chant slogans, or even communicate with the international press was swiftly neutralized. Dozens were arrested, including, notably, the president of a local child protection association who was briefly detained merely for speaking to the media.

This heavy-handed approach sends a clear message: public demonstrations, especially those organized outside official channels and echoing the dangerous specter of 2011, will not be tolerated. While this strategy may restore immediate physical order, history suggests it is a temporary fix. Suppressing the expression of discontent does not quell the root causes of the anger—it merely forces it back into the digital shadows, ready to re-emerge later.

  1. The Singapore Connection: Lessons on Stability and Social Safety Nets

Why should this crisis in North Africa matter to policymakers and citizens in the stable, prosperous island nation of Singapore? The connection lies not in direct trade impact or geopolitical proximity, but in the vital lessons surrounding governance, resilience, and the maintenance of the social contract.

Singapore has famously built its success on two pillars: robust economic growth and an explicit commitment to delivering world-class public services (housing, health, and education). The Moroccan situation serves as a powerful cautionary tale illustrating the consequences of fundamental failures in both these areas:

A. The Primacy of Public Services as Stability Anchors

For Singapore, efficiency and quality in public health and education are not just social programs—they are essential components of political stability. Morocco shows what happens when these anchors fail. When healthcare is denied and education leads nowhere, the population loses faith, leading to social fragmentation and protest. The lesson for Singapore is simple: continuous investment and meticulous quality control over public services are the most effective stabilizers against street volatility.

B. Managing Digital Discontent

While Singapore maintains measures to manage online misinformation and foreign interference, the GenZ 212 phenomenon highlights the raw, organic power of anonymous, digitally native movements. No sophisticated firewall can stop frustrated young people from organizing via TikTok. The challenge for stable governments everywhere is not simply to suppress digital organization, but to preempt it by addressing the core socio-economic frustrations before they translate into viral calls for mass action.

C. The Cost of Youth Unemployment

Singapore, while enjoying a lower overall unemployment rate, must continually ensure its economic growth remains competitive enough to absorb highly educated graduates. The 35.8% youth unemployment rate in Morocco is a red flag on the global political stability radar. It underscores that neglecting the employment pipeline for graduates is not just an economic inefficiency, but a ticking social and political time bomb, capable of destabilizing even regions perceived as stable.

Conclusion: The Persistence of the Algorithm

The arrests have, for now, broken the momentum of the GenZ 212 street protests. Yet, the underlying crisis of youth joblessness and failing essential services remains unresolved.

In the age of algorithmic organization, movements do not require a physical headquarters or a visible leader; they reside in the shared frustration echoing across Discord servers and TikTok feeds. While Morocco has demonstrated its capacity for rapid suppression, the fight for “freedom, dignity, and social justice” has merely shifted back to the digital domain, waiting for the next spark.

For global stakeholders, and for models of governance predicated on stability like Singapore, the Moroccan crisis is a sharp reminder: high-quality public services and tangible economic opportunity are not optional luxuries; they are indispensable foundations of lasting peace. Ignore the echoes of GenZ 212, and the consequences will eventually reverberate globally.

Morocco’s GenZ Protests: A Deep Analysis of Youth Discontent and Implications for Singapore

Introduction: A New Generation Takes to the Streets

Morocco is witnessing a significant moment in its contemporary political landscape. For three consecutive days ending September 30, 2025, youth-led protests have erupted across multiple cities, marking what could be the most substantial wave of civil unrest since the Arab Spring-inspired demonstrations of 2011. Unlike previous protest movements, this mobilization is distinctly digital-native, organized by an anonymous collective calling itself “GenZ 212” through platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and the gaming application Discord.

The protests, ostensibly focused on demanding improvements to public health and education systems, represent something far more complex: a generation’s frustration with unfulfilled promises, economic stagnation, and what they perceive as systemic failures in governance. Understanding these protests requires examining not just their immediate causes, but the deeper socioeconomic currents driving Morocco’s youth to the streets despite heavy-handed security responses.

The Anatomy of GenZ 212: Digital Organization in Authoritarian Spaces

The emergence of GenZ 212 as an organizing force represents a significant evolution in protest movements within North Africa and the Middle East. Several factors make this group particularly noteworthy:

Digital-First Strategy: Unlike the 2011 protests that relied heavily on Facebook and Twitter, GenZ 212 has adapted to the current digital landscape. By utilizing TikTok for rapid information dissemination, Instagram for visual documentation, and Discord for secure coordination, the movement demonstrates sophisticated digital literacy. Discord, in particular, offers encrypted communications and the ability to create temporary, invitation-only servers that are difficult for authorities to infiltrate or monitor.

Anonymous and Leaderless: The deliberately anonymous structure of GenZ 212 makes it resistant to traditional government suppression tactics. There are no prominent leaders to arrest, no organizational headquarters to raid, and no formal membership lists to target. This diffuse structure, while making coordination more challenging, also makes the movement remarkably resilient.

Symbolic Naming: The “212” in the group’s name refers to Morocco’s international dialing code, a subtle assertion of national identity and unity. By branding themselves as “GenZ,” they explicitly frame this as a generational struggle, distinguishing themselves from previous protest movements and signaling that they represent the concerns of Morocco’s youngest adults.

The Triggers: Health and Education as Flashpoints

While the immediate catalyst for the protests was poor hospital conditions in Agadir, the choice of healthcare and education as focal points is deeply strategic and emotionally resonant.

Healthcare System Failures: Morocco’s public healthcare system has been under severe strain for years. The COVID-19 pandemic exposed critical weaknesses: understaffed hospitals, inadequate medical supplies, long wait times, and a stark disparity between care available to the wealthy and that accessible to ordinary Moroccans. For young people watching family members struggle to access basic care, or witnessing preventable deaths due to system inadequacies, healthcare represents a visceral failure of the social contract.

The protests in Agadir that sparked the wider movement reportedly involved incidents where patients died waiting for care, and where hospital staff were overwhelmed to the point of breakdown. These are not abstract policy failures but concrete human tragedies that resonate deeply with young people who expect their government to provide basic social services.

Education System Inadequacies: Morocco’s education system faces its own crisis. Despite government investments, issues persist: overcrowded classrooms, outdated curricula, insufficient teacher training, and a mismatch between educational outcomes and labor market needs. Perhaps most frustratingly for young Moroccans, the system produces graduates who cannot find employment that matches their qualifications.

The statistic that 19% of graduates are unemployed is particularly damning. These are young people who followed the prescribed path—stayed in school, earned degrees, played by the rules—only to find themselves without opportunities. This creates a particular kind of disillusionment that fuels protest movements.

The Economic Context: A Generation Without Prospects

To fully understand these protests, one must examine the economic reality facing Morocco’s youth:

Staggering Youth Unemployment: With overall unemployment at 12.8% and youth unemployment reaching 35.8%, more than one in three young Moroccans cannot find work. This isn’t just an economic statistic; it represents millions of individual stories of frustration, delayed life plans, and thwarted ambitions. Young people cannot start families, achieve independence, or build the futures they were promised.

The Graduate Paradox: The 19% unemployment rate among graduates is particularly bitter. These young people invested years in education, often at significant family expense, with the understanding that degrees would lead to stable employment and upward mobility. Instead, they find themselves competing for limited positions, often accepting jobs far below their qualifications or leaving Morocco entirely in search of opportunities abroad.

Brain Drain Concerns: While not explicitly mentioned in the protests, Morocco faces significant brain drain as educated youth seek opportunities in Europe, the Gulf states, or North America. This emigration represents a loss of human capital that the country can ill afford, and for those who remain, it reinforces the sense that Morocco cannot provide for its own young people.

Informal Economy Dominance: Much of Morocco’s economy operates informally, meaning young workers often lack job security, benefits, or legal protections. This precarity compounds the frustration evident in the protests.

Government Response: Repression as Policy

The Moroccan government’s response to the GenZ 212 protests has been swift and uncompromising, revealing important aspects of the regime’s approach to dissent:

Preemptive Suppression: Rather than allowing protests to develop and then dispersing them, authorities have attempted to prevent gatherings before they can form. This preemptive approach involves heavy security deployments, plainclothes officers infiltrating potential protest sites, and rapid arrests of anyone attempting to organize or participate.

Targeting Documentation: The arrest of Najat Anouar, president of a child protection association who was speaking to media, is particularly revealing. By detaining someone investigating whether minors were being arrested, authorities signal their unwillingness to tolerate scrutiny of their methods. This suggests the government is more concerned with controlling the narrative than with addressing the underlying grievances.

Silence as Strategy: As of the article’s publication, neither the government nor judicial authorities had issued statements about the protests or arrests. The Interior Ministry did not respond to Reuters’ request for comment. This silence is deliberate—by refusing to acknowledge the protests officially, authorities hope to deny them legitimacy and prevent them from becoming a sustained national conversation.

The Risks of Repression: History suggests that heavy-handed responses to youth protests can backfire. The 2011 demonstrations that prompted constitutional reforms began with similar grievances and government resistance. If the current protests are sustained or escalate, the government may find itself forced to make concessions or risk wider unrest.

Historical Echoes: 2011 and the Limits of Reform

The protesters’ chant of “freedom, dignity, and social justice” deliberately evokes the 2011 Arab Spring demonstrations that swept through Morocco and the broader region. This connection is significant:

The 2011 Precedent: In 2011, Morocco experienced its own version of Arab Spring protests, though they remained relatively peaceful compared to upheavals in Tunisia, Egypt, Libya, and Syria. King Mohammed VI responded by proposing constitutional reforms that were approved in a referendum, devolving some powers from the monarchy to elected government while maintaining the king’s fundamental authority.

Unfulfilled Promises: Fourteen years later, many young Moroccans feel those reforms were insufficient. While Morocco avoided the violence and instability that engulfed some neighbors, the underlying economic and social problems persist. GenZ 212’s use of the 2011 slogans suggests they view that movement as unfinished business.

A Different Generation: The young people protesting today were children or early teenagers in 2011. They’ve grown up in post-reform Morocco and judge the system not by whether it’s better than the authoritarian past, but by whether it delivers the opportunities and services they believe they deserve. Their expectations are higher, and their patience is shorter.

Regional Context: Morocco hasn’t experienced the upheavals that have affected neighbors like Algeria, where mass protests forced President Bouteflika from power in 2019, or Tunisia, where economic crisis has prompted emigration waves and political instability. However, the regional pattern suggests youth discontent is a persistent feature of North African politics that governments ignore at their peril.

Social Media and Modern Protest: The Digital Battlefield

The GenZ 212 movement represents an important case study in how protest movements have evolved in the digital age:

Platform Selection: The choice of TikTok, Instagram, and Discord reflects careful strategic thinking. TikTok allows for rapid viral spread of short videos showing police actions, hospital conditions, or protest calls. Instagram provides a visual platform for longer-form documentation and storytelling. Discord offers secure, real-time coordination that’s harder for authorities to monitor or disrupt than traditional social media.

Content Strategy: Videos circulating on social media showing police dispersing students near university campuses serve multiple purposes: they document government actions, create emotional resonance with viewers, provide proof of participation to would-be protesters, and make it harder for authorities to deny that protests occurred.

International Audience: By organizing on global platforms and engaging with international media like Reuters, GenZ 212 ensures the protests receive attention beyond Morocco’s borders. This international awareness can provide some protection against severe repression and pressure the government to respond to grievances.

Government Counter-Measures: While not detailed in the available information, Moroccan authorities have historically attempted to monitor social media, track organizers, and occasionally restrict internet access during periods of unrest. The protesters’ use of multiple platforms and anonymous organization makes such counter-measures less effective.

Implications for Morocco’s Future

These protests, regardless of their immediate outcome, signal important shifts in Moroccan society:

Generational Politics: GenZ 212 represents the political awakening of a generation that came of age after the 2011 reforms. Their willingness to organize and protest despite risks suggests a cohort that won’t accept the status quo quietly.

Social Contract Breakdown: The focus on healthcare and education indicates that young Moroccans feel the government has failed to uphold its end of the social contract. In exchange for political stability and limited democracy, citizens expected economic opportunity and social services. When those aren’t delivered, the legitimacy of the arrangement comes into question.

Economic Imperatives: With more than a third of young people unemployed, Morocco faces a demographic time bomb. These aren’t just potential protesters; they’re unused human capital, frustrated consumers who can’t participate fully in the economy, and potential emigrants who might take their skills elsewhere.

Reform Pressures: If protests continue or escalate, the government may face a choice between sustained repression and meaningful reforms to healthcare, education, and economic policy. The path chosen will shape Morocco’s trajectory for years to come.

Singapore’s Stake: Strategic and Economic Interests

While geographically distant, Singapore has several interests affected by stability and conditions in Morocco:

Economic and Trade Relations

Bilateral Trade: Singapore and Morocco maintain modest but growing trade relations. According to available data, bilateral trade has expanded in recent years, with Singapore exporting machinery, electronics, and pharmaceuticals while importing Moroccan phosphates, textiles, and agricultural products. Political instability could disrupt these trade flows.

Investment Concerns: Singapore sovereign wealth funds and private investors have exposure to North African markets, including Morocco. Political instability typically depresses investment returns and can make it difficult to repatriate funds or conduct normal business operations. Prolonged unrest could force reassessment of Morocco’s investment attractiveness.

Morocco as Regional Hub: Morocco has positioned itself as a business gateway to Africa and a manufacturing hub for European markets. Singapore companies using Morocco as a platform for broader regional operations would be affected by sustained instability.

Strategic and Diplomatic Dimensions

Red Sea and Mediterranean Security: Morocco’s strategic position at the entrance to the Mediterranean makes it important for global shipping routes. Singapore, as a major maritime hub, has interests in Mediterranean stability. While these protests don’t directly threaten shipping lanes, escalation could have broader regional implications.

Counterterrorism Cooperation: Morocco is a key partner in counterterrorism efforts in North Africa and the Sahel region. Singapore cooperates with Morocco on security matters through various multilateral frameworks. Domestic instability could distract from or complicate these security partnerships.

Democratic Governance Models: Singapore has traditionally been pragmatic in its diplomatic relations, maintaining ties with various regime types. However, as a nation that has successfully managed its own social pressures through economic development and social services, Singapore might view Morocco’s struggles as a cautionary tale about the consequences of failing to deliver for youth populations.

Lessons for Singapore’s Governance

Youth Expectations Management: Morocco’s crisis offers lessons for Singapore about managing youth expectations. Singapore’s unemployment rate is far lower, but the government remains vigilant about ensuring young Singaporeans have opportunities and that social services remain world-class. The Moroccan situation illustrates what can happen when a generation feels the social contract has been broken.

Social Media Mobilization: GenZ 212’s digital-first approach demonstrates how quickly youth movements can organize across multiple platforms. Singapore authorities have long understood the importance of monitoring and engaging with online sentiment, but the Moroccan protests show how sophisticated youth-led movements have become.

Healthcare and Education Investment: The protests’ focus on healthcare and education validates Singapore’s continued heavy investment in both sectors. The government’s commitment to maintaining excellent public healthcare and education systems isn’t just good policy; it’s politically essential for maintaining social stability and legitimacy.

Economic Opportunity: Perhaps the most important lesson is the criticality of maintaining economic opportunity for youth. Singapore’s relatively low youth unemployment is a key factor in social stability, and the government works actively to match educational outcomes with labor market needs. Morocco’s 35.8% youth unemployment rate shows what happens when this connection breaks down.

Singapore’s Diaspora and Regional Connections

Singaporean Muslim Community: Singapore’s Muslim community, while primarily Malay, maintains cultural and religious connections to the broader Islamic world, including North Africa. Conditions affecting Muslims globally, including in Morocco, can influence community sentiment in Singapore, though the connection is usually indirect.

Southeast Asian Stability Comparisons: Events in Morocco contribute to ongoing discussions about governance, stability, and development in the Muslim world. Singapore often engages in Track II diplomacy and knowledge-sharing about successful governance models, and the Moroccan situation provides context for these discussions.

Broader Implications: Youth Protests in the 2020s

The GenZ 212 protests should be understood as part of a global pattern of youth-led movements challenging established systems:

Common Grievances: From Hong Kong to Chile to Lebanon to Morocco, young people worldwide are protesting economic inequality, lack of opportunity, government corruption, and climate inaction. While specific triggers vary, the underlying frustrations are remarkably similar.

Organizational Evolution: Modern youth movements are increasingly decentralized, digitally organized, and leaderless. This makes them resilient but also sometimes unfocused, capable of mobilizing quickly but struggling to translate protest energy into concrete political outcomes.

Government Responses: Authorities worldwide are grappling with how to respond to these movements. Heavy-handed repression can backfire by generating sympathy and international condemnation. Co-option attempts often fail because leaderless movements have no one to co-opt. Many governments find themselves without effective tools to address youth discontent.

Long-term Trajectories: These movements rarely achieve immediate, comprehensive victories. Instead, they often contribute to gradual shifts in political consciousness, force issues onto public agendas, and set the stage for future mobilizations. The true impact of GenZ 212 may not be apparent for years.

Conclusion: An Uncertain Path Forward

As of September 30, 2025, Morocco’s GenZ 212 protests represent an evolving situation whose ultimate outcome remains uncertain. Several scenarios are possible:

Scenario 1: Suppression and Fizzle – The government’s security measures prove effective, arrests deter further participation, and the movement gradually loses momentum without achieving concessions. This is the outcome authorities clearly prefer, but it risks storing up resentment for future explosions.

Scenario 2: Sustained Low-Level Mobilization – Protests continue sporadically despite repression, becoming a persistent feature of Moroccan political life without forcing major changes. This represents a manageable challenge for the government but a symbol of youth frustration.

Scenario 3: Escalation and Concessions – Protests grow in size and scope despite repression, forcing the government to make concrete commitments on healthcare, education, and economic policy. This would represent a meaningful victory for the movement but would require sustained mobilization despite risks.

Scenario 4: Broader Instability – Protests trigger wider unrest, connecting with other grievances and populations, potentially threatening political stability. This is the nightmare scenario for the government and would have significant regional implications.

For Singapore, the Moroccan situation serves as both a distant concern and a case study in governance challenges. While direct impacts are limited, the protests reinforce important lessons about the necessity of delivering for youth populations, maintaining excellent social services, and ensuring economic opportunity.

The story of GenZ 212 is ultimately about a generation demanding that their society live up to its promises. Whether Morocco rises to meet that challenge, and how Singapore and other nations learn from Morocco’s experience, will shape governance and stability in the years ahead. As young protesters brave arrest to demand “freedom, dignity, and social justice,” they’re not just challenging their government—they’re asking fundamental questions about the social contract in the 21st century that resonate far beyond Morocco’s borders.

Recommendations

For Moroccan Authorities:

  • Engage meaningfully with youth grievances rather than relying solely on suppression
  • Provide concrete timelines and commitments for healthcare and education improvements
  • Create economic opportunities through reforms that encourage job creation
  • Allow space for peaceful expression of dissent to prevent radicalization

For Singapore:

  • Continue prioritizing youth employment and economic opportunity
  • Maintain world-class healthcare and education systems
  • Monitor the evolution of digital-first protest movements
  • Strengthen dialogue with youth populations to address grievances before they escalate
  • Consider Morocco’s experience in regional stability assessments and investment decisions

For International Observers:

  • Recognize youth unemployment as a critical stability indicator
  • Support civil society organizations working on education and healthcare in Morocco
  • Maintain pressure on Moroccan authorities to respect freedom of assembly
  • Consider how development assistance can be targeted toward youth opportunity creation

The GenZ 212 protests may be happening in Morocco, but their implications ripple outward, offering lessons and warnings for governments worldwide about the consequences of failing to deliver for the next generation.

Maxthon

In an age where the digital world is in constant flux, and our interactions online are ever-evolving, the importance of prioritizing individuals as they navigate the expansive internet cannot be overstated. The myriad of elements that shape our online experiences calls for a thoughtful approach to selecting web browsers—one that places a premium on security and user privacy. Amidst the multitude of browsers vying for users’ loyalty, Maxthon emerges as a standout choice, providing a trustworthy solution to these pressing concerns, all without any cost to the user.

Maxthon browser Windows 11 support

Maxthon, with its advanced features, boasts a comprehensive suite of built-in tools designed to enhance your online privacy. Among these tools are a highly effective ad blocker and a range of anti-tracking mechanisms, each meticulously crafted to fortify your digital sanctuary. This browser has carved out a niche for itself, particularly with its seamless compatibility with Windows 11, further solidifying its reputation in an increasingly competitive market.

In a crowded landscape of web browsers, Maxthon has forged a distinct identity through its unwavering dedication to offering a secure and private browsing experience. Fully aware of the myriad threats lurking in the vast expanse of cyberspace, Maxthon works tirelessly to safeguard your personal information. Utilizing state-of-the-art encryption technology, it ensures that your sensitive data remains protected and confidential throughout your online adventures.

What truly sets Maxthon apart is its commitment to enhancing user privacy during every moment spent online. Each feature of this browser has been meticulously designed with the user’s privacy in mind. Its powerful ad-blocking capabilities work diligently to eliminate unwanted advertisements, while its comprehensive anti-tracking measures effectively reduce the presence of invasive scripts that could disrupt your browsing enjoyment. As a result, users can traverse the web with newfound confidence and safety.

Moreover, Maxthon’s incognito mode provides an extra layer of security, granting users enhanced anonymity while engaging in their online pursuits. This specialized mode not only conceals your browsing habits but also ensures that your digital footprint remains minimal, allowing for an unobtrusive and liberating internet experience. With Maxthon as your ally in the digital realm, you can explore the vastness of the internet with peace of mind, knowing that your privacy is being prioritized every step of the way.